In a recent exclusive interview with Us Weekly, Jessi Ngatikaura from “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” opened up about her response to Scheana Shay’s allegations regarding an affair involving Marciano Brunette. The drama unfolded after Scheana claimed to have witnessed an encounter between Jessi and Marciano, prompting Jessi to clarify her side of the story.
Jessi expressed her shock upon hearing Scheana’s claims, especially since they had been close friends. “I was really close with her, so I was really shocked to see that,” she said. However, Jessi appreciated that Scheana had given her a heads-up about the podcast episode that would discuss the allegations, allowing her to prepare for the fallout.
To address the situation, Jessi sent Scheana a detailed 10-minute voice message, explaining her perspective. “After it came out, I did send her a 10-minute voice memo going over my side of things because she had never really heard my side. After that, she was like, ‘Oh, this makes a lot of sense,’” Jessi recalled.
The controversy surrounding Marciano Brunette has been a central theme in the second season of “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives.” The season not only explored Marciano’s alleged romantic connection with Demi Engemann but also raised questions about his relationship with Jessi. This all began on “Vanderpump Villa,” where the rumors first surfaced.
Jessi clarified that Scheana had some of the facts wrong regarding the situation. “There were things she didn’t know,” she stated. “So I set the record straight, and we’re good now.” Despite the initial shock, Jessi noted that she and Scheana managed to reconcile after discussing the matter.
Throughout the season, Jessi has denied rumors that she was seen making out with Marciano at TomTom. In a twist, Marciano had previously suggested that he had an affair with Demi before claiming that his involvement was actually with Jessi, who is married to Jordan Ngatikaura. Scheana added fuel to the fire during her podcast, recalling that she had spent time with both Jessi and Marciano on the day of the alleged incident.
“I have Marciano insinuating and alluding to like, ‘Yeah, that happened last night,’” Scheana recounted. Jessi, however, firmly denied any wrongdoing, stating, “No. He went and saw another girl and didn’t want to go back into your house that late in the middle of the night. He asked if he could come crash in my hotel room and he just slept on the little, like, couch chair.”
As the drama unfolds, Jessi hinted that the truth behind Marciano’s claims will be addressed in the upcoming third season of “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives.” “I haven’t spoken to Marciano recently, but you will see in the next season,” she teased. “A lot of stuff comes out about that and just wait and buckle up. It’s going to be a ride.”
Jessi revealed that she learned about Marciano’s claims before they aired, as filming for the next set of episodes was already in progress. “I knew about it because we were already filming the next set of episodes and we were dealing with it in real time. So I knew about it. But seeing it was so much harder than just hearing about it because I had to see the way he said things and what he did say.”
With the second season of “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” ending on a cliffhanger regarding Marciano’s alleged affair with Jessi, fans are eagerly anticipating the third season. The show, which premiered in September 2024, has captivated audiences with its portrayal of the lives of Mormon women navigating complex relationships.
Jessi emphasized that the narrative presented is not the full story. “I’m excited for the next set of episodes where I can tell more about what actually happened,” she shared. She also expressed her thoughts on Marciano’s social media commentary, describing it as “cringey” and suggesting that it may be perceived as an attempt to gain attention. “He had a little credibility in the beginning, but now I think no one believes him. He’s making himself look worse,” she added.
In the meantime, Jessi is also engaging with fans through her partnership with RumChata, offering an exciting opportunity to win a trip to Salt Lake City for a VIP experience. The winner, along with two friends, will enjoy a glam makeover, an intimate meal with Jessi, and a chance to share their favorite soda recipes.
Fans can participate by commenting on RumChata’s Instagram post with their favorite dirty soda recipe and a housewife-style tagline. “I do cola as the base. You can do any base you want, but that’s the one I prefer. Then I do a little bit of coconut creamer and then I do the RumChata,” Jessi explained. “You can do a lemon in there if you want. Extra ice is always my go-to as well. But the RumChata is really creamy, so it kind of mimics the creamer that we do in our normal dirty soda. So it’s perfect.”
As viewers await the next season of “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,” they can stay updated on Jessi’s latest endeavors and the unfolding drama surrounding her and Marciano. The show continues to be available for streaming on Hulu, providing fans with a front-row seat to the lives of these intriguing women.