The cast of the hit series *You* has captivated audiences not only with their on-screen performances but also with their intriguing off-screen romances. Since its premiere on Lifetime in September 2018, the show has evolved from a modest start to a Netflix sensation, showcasing the complex lives of its characters. Led by Penn Badgley as the obsessive Joe Goldberg, the series has delved into themes of love, obsession, and morality, prompting viewers to reflect on the nature of relationships—both fictional and real.
As we take a closer look at the cast’s dating histories, it’s clear that their personal lives have been just as eventful as the narratives they portray. Here’s a rundown of the romantic journeys of some of the main cast members:
Penn Badgley
Before his role as Joe, Penn Badgley was well-known for playing Dan Humphrey on *Gossip Girl*, where he dated co-star Blake Lively from 2007 to 2010. Their off-screen romance added an extra layer of intrigue to their on-screen chemistry. After their split, Badgley dated actress Zoë Kravitz from 2011 to 2013. He eventually found lasting love with Domino Kirke, whom he married in 2017. The couple welcomed their first child in the summer of 2020, and in February 2025, they announced they were expecting twins.
Elizabeth Lail
Elizabeth Lail, who plays the ill-fated Beck, married her longtime love, Nieku Manshadi, in April 2021. The couple’s love story began at a Brooklyn party, and they got engaged in August 2020. Their romance has been a source of joy for fans who appreciate their wholesome relationship.
Shay Mitchell
Shay Mitchell, known for her role as Peach Salinger, shares two children with her partner Matte Babel. Previously, she was linked to NBA star Jimmy Butler and her *Pretty Little Liars* co-star Keegan Allen. Mitchell has often expressed her love for her family and the joy that motherhood brings.
Ambyr Childers
Ambyr Childers, who plays the character Candace, was married to producer Randall Emmett from 2009 until their split in 2015. The couple shares two daughters, London and Rylee. Childers has since focused on her career and personal growth, navigating life as a single mother.
Lou Taylor Pucci
Lou Taylor Pucci, who portrayed Benji, appears to be currently single, according to his social media activity. He was previously linked to actress Kelli Garner in the mid-2000s but has kept his romantic life relatively private since then.
John Stamos
The beloved *90s heartthrob and former *Full House* star, John Stamos, was married to model Rebecca Romijn from 1998 until their divorce in 2004. After a decade, he found love again with actress Caitlin McHugh, marrying her in February 2018. The couple welcomed their son, Billy, just two months later, marking a new chapter in Stamos’s life.
Victoria Pedretti
Victoria Pedretti, who plays Love Quinn, has been relatively private about her personal life. In November 2021, it was confirmed that she was dating her *You* co-star Dylan Arnold. As of July 2025, Pedretti announced her engagement to photographer Ethan DeLorenzo, delighting fans with the news.
Jenna Ortega
Jenna Ortega, featured in season 2, has been linked to younger stars like Asher Angel and Jacob Sartorius but seems to be enjoying her single life at the moment. Her focus remains on her burgeoning career in Hollywood.
Hari Nef
Hari Nef, who played one of Beck’s classmates, has been candid about her dating experiences in the past. However, she currently appears to be single, dedicating her time to her career and personal pursuits.
Kathryn Gallagher
Peter Gallagher’s daughter, Kathryn, played Annika in season 1. She often shares glimpses of her life on social media but has not publicly disclosed any romantic relationships, choosing instead to focus on her music and friendships.
Nicole Kang
Nicole Kang, known for her role in *Batwoman*, is currently prioritizing self-love and personal growth. She has not been linked to anyone romantically, focusing instead on her career and well-being.
Carmela Zumbado
Carmela Zumbado, who starred in season 2, was rumored to be dating co-star James Scully, but these rumors were unsubstantiated. She remains focused on her acting career, enjoying her time in the spotlight.
Robin Lord Taylor
Robin Lord Taylor, known for his role in *Gotham*, has been open about his marriage, which he prefers to keep private. He came out as gay in 2015 and is married to production designer Richard DiBella.
James Scully
James Scully, who has played various roles in television, has also expressed the desire to keep his personal life private. In a past interview, he mentioned that he doesn’t have a specific type when it comes to dating, hinting at his single status.
The cast of *You* continues to intrigue fans with their captivating performances and personal lives. As the series progresses, viewers remain invested not only in the characters’ fates but also in the real-life romances that unfold behind the scenes. With each new season, the complexity of love—both on-screen and off—remains a central theme that resonates deeply with audiences.