In an intriguing twist for fans of reality television, both influencer Serena Kerrigan and Juliette Porter from “Siesta Key” revealed that they were in the running to join the cast of Bravo’s popular series “Summer House.” However, both ultimately decided against participating, leading to a flurry of speculation about what could have been.
On June 23, 2025, during an appearance on Gia Giudice’s podcast “Casual Chaos,” Kerrigan, who boasts nearly 600,000 followers on TikTok, shared her experience with the casting process for “Summer House.” At 31 years old, she confirmed that she was approached for Season 10 and even went through an interview process. “Did they offer and I turned it down? No. I jumped on a call with them,” she explained, indicating her genuine interest in the opportunity. However, she ultimately decided against it, citing her background and personal reasons for her choice.
Kerrigan’s mother worked in unscripted television during her childhood, giving her a unique perspective on the industry. “I saw the behind-the-scenes a lot and I think that it is a scary thing when you’re on these shows … you don’t have control over your edit,” she noted. While she acknowledged that being on the show could be “really fun,” she expressed concerns about her sensitivity and the lack of creative control that comes with reality TV.
Meanwhile, Porter, who starred on “Siesta Key” from 2017 to 2023, also shared her story regarding the “Summer House” casting. On the same day, during an episode of “The Toast” podcast, she revealed that she had previously interviewed for the show. “My old producer on Siesta Key was the casting director last year for Summer House. I did a whole Summer House interview,” she recounted, noting that the process took about three hours. Despite her efforts, she was not selected for the cast, leaving her puzzled about the decision. “I don’t know why they didn’t go for me,” she admitted.
As fans eagerly anticipate the upcoming season of “Summer House,” the show has seen a number of cast changes. Season 9, which premiered in February, featured a diverse group of friends who share a summer house on weekends, including Kyle Cooke, Amanda Batula, Paige DeSorbo, and Lindsay Hubbard, among others. With Season 10 on the horizon, many are curious about the new dynamics and who will be returning after several cast exits.
Kerrigan and Porter’s near-misses with “Summer House” highlight the competitive nature of reality television casting and the personal decisions that often come into play. For Kerrigan, the allure of reality TV was tempered by her desire for creative freedom, while Porter’s experience underscores the unpredictability of casting decisions in the reality TV landscape.
As the filming for Season 10 begins, fans are left to wonder how different the show might have been with Kerrigan and Porter as part of the cast. Their stories serve as a reminder of the complex choices that celebrities make in the pursuit of their careers, particularly in the often tumultuous world of reality television.
With the anticipation building for the new season, viewers can expect a mix of familiar faces and fresh dynamics. As “Summer House” continues to evolve, the show’s ability to attract new talent while retaining its core audience remains a key factor in its ongoing success. Whether or not Kerrigan and Porter will find their way onto reality television in the future remains to be seen, but their stories add an intriguing layer to the ever-changing landscape of Hollywood and reality TV.
As the summer approaches, fans are gearing up for another exciting season of “Summer House,” where friendships, drama, and unforgettable moments await. The casting decisions may have been made, but the stories of those who almost made it serve as a fascinating glimpse into the world of reality television.